Cionci replies to Barnhart and Mazza on the claim of Substantial Error in the Renunciation

4 thoughts on “Cionci replies to Barnhart and Mazza on the claim of Substantial Error in the Renunciation”

  1. This important video DOES HAVE ENGLISH SUBTITLES.
    If you view no other apologia for the continuing papacy of Benedict XVI, see this one as it logically critiques the arguments of all sides of this debate, & the difficulties Bergogolians raise.
    Send it to all those (like many parish priests) who are troubled about Francis, but not yet prepared to say he’s an antipope.

  2. One particularly valuable detail which I drew from this broadcast was the “lack of simultaneity”: that 11 ii ’13 produced a declaration to renounce; come 28 ii, there was none. Some might argue that 11 ii included a “vacatio legis,” but then we’re back to the original issue: the munus was not renounced.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.


This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.