Editor’s Note: The report tonight, from Vatican News, is that the Pope is slightly improving: his renal failure has ceased, his blood tests confirm the improvement from yesterday, the CAT scan from yesterday shows “a normal evolution of his pulmonary inflammatory picture”.
If his light renal failure and anemia were caused by the pharmacological therapies he is receiving, then they would subside when these therapies are reduced. Nothing has been said about the Pope having these issues before. So perhaps this is what is going on.
However, his bad bruises and night-time falls, over the past several months, argue the contrary, namely, that he has suffered from anemia for quite some time. And if so, it is not reasonable to expect a cure for that with a few blood tests and transfusions. On the other hand, if his pharmacological therapies are being reduced, this will only allow the poly-microbic infection of his lungs (which his doctors said was “incurable but controllable”) to return with greater force.
Also, if the Pope is improving, why was he put back on a high-concentration oxygen therapy, a thing which if prolonged can damage the lungs?
And what is a “normal evolution of a pulmonary inflammatory picture”. Normally pneumonia kills you. Being cured of it is not something which normally happens, since the cure of every disease fights against it.
Also, it is said that Pope Francis underwent physiotherapy to help him breathe: this includes exercises which teach a person how to use the musculature of his thorax properly, so as to breathe more efficiently. It is hard to understand how an 88 year old does not know how to breathe correctly, unless his mental awareness is failing or his body has become so bloated that he has to be taught how to breathe better in such an extreme condition of body.
From all of this one must objectively conclude that Pope Francis still has anemia and the statement that his blood tests confirm the improvement of his blood health is a lie, or his lungs are deteriorating and not improving.
And this means, that if he has another breathing crisis he could literally suffocate to death, if not in a hospital when it happens. And this argues that he will have to abdicate.
So, the truth seems better stated in these terms: that the Pope is NOT improving in those areas which are critical.
And since it was reported that he has critical problems which are causing a complex critical condition, the continued failure to detail what these problems are other than pneumonia, leaves the door open to doubts.
From a journalistic point of view, however, I really hope that the news about Pope Francis’ health has not been such a flop, that the doctors would change his therapies so as to be able to publish positive news reports the next day.
Click the image above to read the Italian original. Or click HERE to read an English translation of the Italian version of the release. The actual English official version is much shorter and designed to prevent any such questions or criticisms as I have made here enter the mind of the reader.